When Toni Rachal, the President of Howard University’s tennis team received a racist graphic depicting Ku Klux Klan imagery, she immediately confronted the University of Maryland. She requested in writing that there be meaningful accountability. Following the extensive publicity, the University of Maryland’s tennis club has been suspended indefinitely and a public apology was issued. A contribution was also made to the National Museum of African American History and Culture. While apologies and donations are nice, those actions fall short of making any kind of meaningful change. It is disappointing that an institution of higher education has assumed that an apology without individual accountability and institutional change without addressing anti-Black racism is a satisfactory starting point.
An apology cannot reverse the racial harm caused by the imagery. An apology will not alleviate the fear and discomfort felt by the Black players on UMD tennis club, now knowing some of their teammates sent out such hateful imagery. An apology cannot and does not heal racism and it certainly does not prevent it or stop our bodies from keeping score. It is no surprise that racism has devastating consequences on mental health and on academic performance for black students. Rather than an apology, we need action.
The starting point in addressing, incidence of racism on college campuses and universities must start with immediate action. In the case of UMD, officials were condemning the imagery without fully validating the pain it caused because they cannot even say what exactly they are condemning or who specifically are responsible for such actions to its student body and the broader community impacted. In the team’s public apology it states, “Although we did not intend to share an image evoking hate and racism, we take full responsibility for failing to identify and remove it.” For reference the image sent out to students, depicts a conical shape white hood with round eyeholes cut of the mask. The Ku Klux Klan hood is considered to be the most recognizable symbol of violent, domestic terrorism used by white supremacist in America.
Historically, white supremacist have used pamphlets filled with racist and anti-Semitic imagery to spread racial propaganda. In 2020, the Anti-Defamation League showed that white supremacist had returned to the use of racist pamphlets propaganda especially on college campuses in significant numbers. In fact, in 2017, the American Vanguard, a white supremacist hate group, targeted UMD’s campus and several others with racist fliers. While the racist ideas espoused by the Ku Klux Klan are not limited to anti-Black racism, it appears to be the primary target of this incident. Anti-Black racism is the systemic and deeply rooted form of prejudice, dehumanization and exclusion that targets Black people.
UMD’s campus, along with every institution of higher education, must address how anti-Black racism, continues to thrive on their campuses. Specifically, at UMD, there is a disconnect when the university itself has acknowledged its ties to slavery and racism through its 1856 Project. What is missing in everyone’s apology is how the campus will address anti-Black racism within its student body. How does the university plan to examine how racist ideas circulate and even gain acceptance within its campus walls. Notably, within 24 hours the university provided on-site support to affected students and reached out to the Black student body on campus with supports. However, where was the immediate action that addresses anti-Black racism that led to the creation of the graphic imagery spewing hate towards Black students.
Of all the tennis clubs who were exposed to the imagery, it appears that the only complaint came from Howard University, a Historically Black University. Those who continue to hold anti-Black racist views have experienced no interruption or accountability while Black students are again taught to cope. Institutional change requires action in addressing anti-blackness on campus, which goes beyond sensitivity training.
To be clear, this is not just a UMD problem, 1 in 5 Black college students across the country report experiences of discrimination on campuses. Our institutions have an obligation to protect and prevent students from being continuous targets of hate! Addressing anti-blackness is the proper starting point, not an apology.