Student loans should not be tied to future earnings potential

How do you measure value in an education?

It is no surprise that vulnerable majors and degree programs at the university level in this country are aligned with the public good or services: social work, mental health services, cosmetology, journalism, fine arts, and education.

But even if the Internal Review Services data could potentially be used as a tool to measure the success of programs, it could not measure the full impact of these fields on individuals and communities.

Value is more than dollars.

The Department of Education on social media recently denied media reports that student loans were halted to students pursuing degrees without high salaries and a high return on investment.

The recent post on X reads: “Here’s the truth: we are holding colleges accountable for leaving students worse off than if they never enrolled. Too many graduates report delaying major life milestones like buying a home or starting a family…Federal student loans are not a welfare program for failing college programs. American students deserve education and training pathways that prepare them for the workforce – and transparency about programs that will never pay off.”

Perhaps supporters of these potential policies, a growing bipartisan effort, should be concerned with the lack of financial and institutional support for community members who invest their talents, time, and resources to the bettering of society even at an economic cost to themselves.

And there is no disputing the rising cost of attending college, with the average in-state tuition nearing $10,000 and out of state tuition averaging over $29,000 in recent years, not including housing and other associated costs. With private school costs even higher, it is no surprise that only 12% of Americans view higher education as affordable.

Despite the high cost of attendance and the seemingly low financial return, some intentionally choose careers and livelihoods that are not high earning.

Consider the social worker who is employed at multiple jobs to pay their mortgage and feed their own families who is laboring to support the survival of unhoused children, domestic violence victims, and military veterans. They deserve a better livelihood and not to be discouraged to pursue their passion.

Instead, the Donald Trump administration wants to push young people into careers that support corporations, earnings and not people. There is a discrepancy in earnings across degrees, with those earning degrees in chemical or computer engineering seeing a potential mid-career median wage over $130,000. On the other spectrum, early childhood educators– those first tasked with guiding the learning of our children and by extension society– see a mid-career median wage of just a little more than $50,000. A degree in health services earns just below $70,000.

Even early American industrialists understood the value of supporting artists, museums, writers, and funded the creation of public spaces that we still enjoy today, although doing so while solidifying the class divide which is deepening today. Fans of the HBO series Gilded Age are well-versed in this history and the inner workings of families such as the Astors and fictional Russell’s and are excited to see what troubles brew at the Opera this new season.

But some states such as Texas have already laid the foundation in closing programs, consolidating departments, and ending degrees rooted in a history of community activism, grounded in critical thinking, and providing frameworks to not only question but dismantle systems that continue to harm bodies and perpetuate inequities.

Just like the potential federal intervention in the future of programs not deemed profitable investments, and the closure of programs like what is happening at the University of Texas at Austin,  this effort is serving the same purpose.

It is not only removing safeguards that provide much needed services to vulnerable communities and people but is removing classroom spaces and educators who are providing students the opportunity to question and challenge the systems that got the country to where it is today.

It is impossible to ignore these attacks on the humanities, arts and social sciences, waiting out the next two years of this administration, because it will be difficult to undo the harm it has already normalized and institutionalized.

I see the value in higher education every day. I see it when a former student sends me updates of their classrooms in schools in Oklahoma, Texas, Illinois, and the impact my teaching has on the learning of children.

I see it when my colleagues celebrate the medical school graduation of a student who dared to sit in an ethnic studies classroom because they see these lessons as imperative to their commitment to serve working-class communities who struggle to access quality medical care. I see the engineer student committed to apply the history they learned to the lessening of the environmental impact on their professional lives.

As a faculty member at a large state university, in my own office in one of the leading departments of Latina/o Studies in the U.S., I worry about not only my future, but the future students envision for themselves and their communities.

No government tool can measure that, but it can be used to negatively alter that future.