Two years ago, Republicans thought they had found the future. Donald Trump won 48 percent of Hispanic voters in 2024, up from 36 percent four years earlier, according to the Pew Research Center’s study of validated voters. Some in our party called it a realignment. This month, voters reminded us that a realignment is something you earn every election, not something you declare once.
The warning signs came early. In October, an NBC News/Telemundo poll found Latino voters preferring Democratic control of Congress by 24 points, double the margin of 2024. Only 20 percent approved of the president’s handling of the cost of living. On Nov. 3, roughly six in ten Latino voters backed Democrats for the House, according to the AP Voter Poll, and a post-election UnidosUS survey found that about one in six Latinos who voted for Trump in 2024 crossed over to Democratic House candidates.
Democrats will read those numbers and conclude that Hispanic voters have come home. They would be making the same mistake we made.
Look at the trend line, not the snapshot. Democrats won 69 percent of the Latino House vote in 2018, 63 percent in 2020, 60 percent in 2022 and 54 percent in 2024, according to exit polls. That is not the profile of a captive constituency. It is the profile of a swing electorate that rewards whoever delivers and punishes whoever doesn’t. Pew found that most Latinos who voted for Trump say what happens to Latinos as a group affects their own lives “not too much” or “not at all.” These are voters who see themselves as workers, parents, churchgoers and taxpayers, not as a bloc to be managed by consultants of either party.
Nowhere is that more true, or more consequential, than among Latino seniors.
Hispanic Americans 65 and older are the most reliable voters in their community. In 2020, about half of eligible Hispanic seniors cast ballots, compared with roughly a third of those 18 to 24. And their numbers are about to surge. There were about 4.6 million Hispanic Americans 65 and older in 2019, roughly 9 percent of the older population. By 2060, they are projected to number nearly 20 million, more than one in five older Americans, and along the way they are on track to become the largest minority group among America’s seniors.
That is a voting bloc that shows up, that is among the fastest-growing groups of retirees in the country, and that neither party has locked down.
What do these voters want? The same thing every senior I talk to wants: to know the check will come, the doctor will see them and the grocery bill won’t eat their savings. For Latino seniors the stakes are sharper. Roughly half of older Hispanic Social Security beneficiaries rely on it for 90 percent or more of their income. Many spent their working lives in physically demanding jobs without a pension. When prices climb and the retirement trust fund’s projected 2032 exhaustion date draws closer, they feel it first.
That is where Republicans lost the argument this year, and where we can win it back. Not with slogans, and not by assuming that faith and family alone will carry the day, though both matter enormously in this community. We win by showing, in plain terms, that we have a plan to keep Social Security and Medicare solvent without raising taxes on the working families who fund them, to bring down the cost of prescription drugs and groceries, and to treat Hispanic grandparents as the patriotic, hardworking Americans they are. Tone matters, too. Voters notice when a party talks about their neighbors as a problem rather than as fellow citizens.
Democrats have their own reckoning coming. They spent decades treating the Hispanic vote as an entitlement, and 2024 showed what happens when that assumption collides with reality. A midterm protest vote is not a lifetime pledge.
The lesson of the last two elections is simple. The Hispanic vote, and especially the Hispanic senior vote, belongs to no one. It goes to the party that shows up, listens and delivers. Republicans proved in 2024 that we can compete for it. Now we have to prove we deserve it.